Mediterranean vs Keto: A Cardiologist Compares Heart Health, Cholesterol, and Long-Term Safety

As America’s Cardiologist, I’ve spent my career studying how nutrition, cholesterol, and lifestyle choices impact heart disease—the number one cause of death worldwide. I spend countless hours a day educating patient online.

I am a board-certified cardiologist, lipidologist, professor of medicine, published researcher, and nutrition expert. I’ve trained physicians, advised institutions, and educated millions of patients on how to protect their hearts using evidence-based strategies—not diet trends.

When patients ask me to compare the Mediterranean diet and the ketogenic (keto) diet, I approach the question through a cardiologist’s lens: cardiovascular risk reduction, cholesterol management, inflammation, and long-term safety—not just short-term weight loss.

What Is The Best Heart Healthy Diet?

If you search online for the “best diet,” two names dominate the conversation: the Mediterranean diet and the ketogenic (keto) diet.
One is consistently ranked as the healthiest diet in the world. The other is one of the most popular weight-loss approaches of the last decade.

As a cardiologist, I’m often asked:
“Which is better for my heart — Mediterranean or keto?”

The answer depends on what outcome you care about most: short-term weight loss, cholesterol levels, heart disease prevention, or long-term sustainability.

What Is the Mediterranean Diet?

The Mediterranean diet is based on traditional eating patterns from countries like Greece, Italy, and Spain. It emphasizes:
- Vegetables, fruits, legumes, and whole grains
- Olive oil as the primary fat
- Nuts and seeds
- Fish and seafood
- Moderate dairy and poultry
- Minimal red meat and processed foods

It is not a low-carb diet and not a vegetarian diet, but it is plant-forward and minimally processed.

Why Cardiologists Favor the Mediterranean Diet

The Mediterranean diet is supported by decades of research showing it can:
- Reduce heart attack and stroke risk
- Improve cholesterol profiles
- Lower inflammation
- Improve blood sugar control
- Support long-term adherence

It aligns closely with American Heart Association (AHA) dietary principles and is repeatedly ranked #1 for overall health.

What Is the Keto Diet?

The ketogenic diet is a very low-carbohydrate, high-fat diet designed to push the body into ketosis, where fat is used as the primary fuel source.

Typical keto macronutrient ratios:
- 70–80% fat
- 10–20% protein
- 5–10% carbohydrates

Foods often include meat, butter, cheese, eggs, oils, and cream, with very limited fruits, grains, and legumes.

Mediterranean vs Keto: Heart Health Comparison

To help patients clearly understand how different eating patterns affect heart health, I developed a visual diet comparison graphic that evaluates popular diets through a cardiologist’s lens.

Rather than focusing on weight loss or macronutrient trends, the graphic scores each diet based on core American Heart Association–aligned principles, including:

• Emphasis on vegetables, fruits, and whole foods
• Quality of fats (unsaturated vs saturated)
• Degree of food processing
• Fiber intake from whole grains and legumes
• Added sugar and sodium exposure

Each diet is then placed into a tier system—from most heart-supportive to least—using a color-coded scorecard. Green indicates strong alignment with cardiovascular guidelines, yellow suggests mixed or conditional benefit, and red highlights patterns that may raise concern for long-term heart health.

When viewed through this framework, Mediterranean-style diets consistently rank in the highest tier. They score well across nearly every category, particularly for fat quality, plant diversity, and sustainability.

Ketogenic-style diets, while effective for short-term metabolic changes in some individuals, tend to score lower because they restrict heart-protective foods such as whole grains and legumes and often rely heavily on saturated fats. This does not mean keto is universally harmful—but it does mean it is not optimized for long-term cardiovascular protection.

The purpose of this graphic is not to declare a single ‘perfect’ diet, but to give patients a clear, evidence-based way to understand how different dietary patterns support—or strain—the cardiovascular system over time.

How to Interpret the Cardiologist Diet Comparison Graphic

Weight Loss

Keto often produces faster short-term weight loss, especially in the first 3–6 months.
Mediterranean weight loss is typically slower but more sustainable long-term.

From a cardiology standpoint, sustainable weight loss matters more than rapid loss.

Cholesterol and LDL

Keto can raise LDL (“bad”) cholesterol in many individuals, especially when high in saturated fats.
The Mediterranean diet consistently lowers LDL and improves HDL (“good”) cholesterol.

For heart disease prevention, Mediterranean clearly outperforms keto.

Inflammation and Blood Vessel Health

Keto is very pro-inflammation and destroys vascular health.
The Mediterranean diet has strong evidence showing reduced inflammation and improved endothelial function.

Nutrient Quality and Food Variety

Keto restricts fruits, whole grains, and legumes.
The Mediterranean diet encourages dietary diversity and nutrient density.

Long-Term Safety and Sustainability

Keto is difficult to maintain long-term and lacks strong long-term cardiovascular safety data.
The Mediterranean diet is supported by decades of population and clinical studies and is easier to maintain as a lifestyle.

Cardiologist’s Verdict

As a practicing cardiologist and lipid specialist, my recommendation is clear.

If your primary goal is rapid short-term weight loss, keto may be appropriate for select individuals—but only with medical supervision and careful cholesterol monitoring.

However, for the vast majority of patients I see in clinic—especially those with elevated cholesterol, a family history of heart disease, or long-term cardiovascular risk—the Mediterranean diet is the foundation I recommend. It is the diet most consistently supported by cardiology research, professional guidelines, and real-world patient outcomes.

Who Should Be Careful With Keto

The medical community does not recommend keto or carnivore style diets based on many of these factors. However, some people may still opt to try this.

You should talk to your physician before starting keto if you have:
- High LDL cholesterol
- A history of heart disease
- A strong family history of heart attacks
- Kidney disease

Final Thoughts On the Healthiest Cardiology Diet?

Keto is a short-term metabolic tool that can be dangerous. If you have known heart disease, you should avoid. If you don't want heart disease ever, you should also avoid keto.
The Mediterranean diet is a long-term heart-health strategy.

As a cardiologist, the most important question is not which diet helps you lose weight fastest, but which diet protects your heart for the next 20 years.

As America’s Cardiologist, my mission is not to promote a trendy diet, but to empower you with evidence-based guidance that protects your heart for decades to come.

In depth Mediterranean Diet Research Review
In depth Keto Carnivore Diet Research Review
In depth Red Meat Diet Research Review

In depth look at CT Scans of Coronary Arteries Of Keto Dieters